The Senate impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte will resume on December 1 following a November 20 hearing that raised further questions about financial transactions involving CALE88 Foods Corp., a company partly owned by her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio.
The hearing also resulted in a show-cause order against Duterte’s spokesperson, Paolo Panelo, over comments concerning senator-judges.
Defense Witness Questioned Over CALE88 Transactions
Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo appeared as a defense witness to discuss CALE88 Foods Corp.’s registration and business operations.
During questioning, senator-judges examined a discrepancy between approximately ₱208 million in sales reported to the Board of Investments from 2022 to 2025 and approximately ₱767 million in foreign remittances identified in Anti-Money Laundering Council records previously introduced by prosecutors.
Rodolfo acknowledged that he could not explain the difference.
The defense maintained that the company was a legitimate registered business and indicated that additional evidence would be presented to address questions about its operations.
Senator Panfilo Lacson said the company’s legal existence was not in dispute, but questioned whether supporting shipping and business records could explain the financial transactions.
Questions Over Production Capacity
Senator Risa Hontiveros also questioned CALE88’s reported banana-chip production volume and workforce figures.
The company’s submissions to different government agencies contained differing employee counts, prompting questions about the scale of its operations.
Rodolfo said he could not independently assess its actual production capacity because he had not personally inspected the factory.
These discrepancies remain matters for examination and do not establish that the company engaged in illegal activity.
Senate Issues Show-Cause Order Against Panelo
The impeachment court also approved a show-cause order directing Duterte spokesperson Paolo Panelo to explain public remarks concerning the impartiality of senator-judges.
Panelo has defended his comments as an exercise of free speech.
The order does not constitute a final finding of contempt.
Trial to Resume December 1
Presiding officer Senator Francis Escudero announced that impeachment hearings would resume on December 1.
Defense counsel Sheila Sison explained that upcoming defense witnesses were unavailable for the initially proposed November 26 and 27 dates.
The Senate is also deliberating on the proposed 2027 national budget.
Further December hearings are expected as the defense continues presenting its case.
What Happens Next?
The Senate impeachment court will continue examining Article II, the remaining impeachment charge involving alleged unexplained wealth, asset declarations and business interests.
The defense may present additional witnesses and documents addressing the financial transactions questioned during the November 20 hearing.
No impeachment verdict has been issued. The allegations remain contested, and the Senate impeachment court has not determined that the questioned transactions constitute wrongdoing.
Sources:

